The phrase represents a specific labor agreement document. This document, typically in a portable document format (PDF), outlines the terms and conditions agreed upon between the International Longshore and Warehouse Union (ILWU) and employers for the year 2023. It serves as a legally binding understanding governing wages, benefits, working conditions, and other aspects of employment for union members.
Such an agreement is significant because it directly impacts the livelihoods of longshore workers and the operational efficiency of ports. Historically, these contracts have played a crucial role in shaping labor relations on the West Coast and influencing supply chain dynamics. Stable and well-negotiated agreements contribute to economic stability and prevent disruptions in the movement of goods.
Understanding the details contained within a document of this nature requires careful examination of its various sections. Key areas of interest typically include compensation structures, healthcare provisions, job security measures, and dispute resolution processes. Analyzing these components provides a comprehensive view of the agreement’s overall impact.
1. Wage Increases
Within the pages of the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf,” the section dedicated to wage increases represents more than just numbers; it reflects the culmination of negotiations, the acknowledgment of labor’s value, and the economic realities facing longshore workers. It’s a tangible representation of the union’s efforts to secure a fair share for its members.
-
Cost of Living Adjustments (COLA)
COLA provisions are designed to protect workers’ purchasing power in the face of inflation. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” outlines how wages will be adjusted based on changes in the Consumer Price Index (CPI). For example, if the CPI rises by 3%, wages may be adjusted upwards by a similar percentage, ensuring that workers can maintain their standard of living. Without COLA, real wages would decline during periods of high inflation.
-
Base Wage Increases
Beyond COLA, the agreement typically includes scheduled base wage increases over the life of the contract. These increases reflect improved productivity and profitability, and a direct acknowledgment of the workers’ contributions. For instance, the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” might stipulate a 2% annual base wage increase. Such increases can significantly boost earnings over the contract’s term.
-
Skill-Based Pay
Certain positions or specialized skills might warrant higher pay. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” may outline specific rates for skilled positions, incentivizing workers to acquire new competencies and improving overall workforce capabilities. Examples might include higher rates for crane operators or mechanics who possess specialized certifications.
-
Impact on Port Competitiveness
Wage increases impact the competitiveness of West Coast ports. Higher labor costs can potentially lead to increased shipping rates, influencing decisions made by shipping companies. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” is therefore a strategic document, balancing the needs of workers with the economic realities of the global shipping industry. The resulting balance helps ensure the long-term viability of the ports.
The wage increases outlined within the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” have far-reaching consequences. They influence individual worker finances, the economic stability of port communities, and the global competitiveness of West Coast ports. These increases underscore the critical role of collective bargaining in shaping economic outcomes and ensuring fair labor practices.
2. Healthcare Benefits
The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” contained more than just figures and clauses; it held the promise of security. Within its pages, the section detailing healthcare benefits represented a lifeline, a shield against the uncertainties of life for longshore workers and their families. The physical demands of the job, the inherent risks of working on docks surrounded by heavy machinery and towering stacks of containers, made comprehensive healthcare not a luxury, but a necessity. Without adequate coverage outlined in that document, a single accident or unexpected illness could financially cripple a family, turning hard-earned livelihoods into mountains of debt. The weight of this reality rested heavily on the negotiating table during contract talks.
Consider the story of a crane operator, a veteran of thirty years on the docks. His steady hands had guided countless containers, his expertise vital to the port’s efficiency. But years of climbing, lifting, and working in all weather conditions had taken their toll. When a persistent cough led to a diagnosis of a respiratory illness, it was the healthcare benefits enshrined in the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” that provided access to specialized treatment. Without that coverage, the operator might have faced insurmountable medical bills and a premature end to his career. This example, mirrored in countless other stories, illustrates the direct and profound impact of these negotiated benefits.
The healthcare provisions detailed in the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” served as more than just insurance policies. They represented a commitment, a recognition of the human cost of labor. These benefits protected not only the physical well-being of workers, but also their peace of mind, allowing them to focus on their jobs with the knowledge that their families were secure. This section of the contract was a testament to the union’s role in safeguarding the health and welfare of its members, an enduring legacy documented in the digital ink of that single PDF file.
3. Automation Concerns
The specter of automation loomed large during the negotiations that led to the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf.” The march of technology, with its promise of efficiency and reduced costs, cast a shadow over the docks, threatening the livelihoods of longshore workers who had for generations relied on the steady rhythm of loading and unloading ships. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” became the battleground where these concerns were addressed, the document itself a shield against the potential displacement of human labor by machines. The union recognized the inevitability of technological advancement, yet its priority remained protecting its members from the harshest consequences of this change. This tension fueled intense debates and shaped some of the most crucial aspects of the agreement.
One real-world example illustrates the gravity of these automation concerns. At one port, the introduction of automated cargo handling systems sparked a wave of anxiety among workers. The initial plan proposed a significant reduction in the workforce, prompting the union to demand guarantees against job losses in the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf.” The resulting agreement included provisions for retraining programs, ensuring that workers could acquire the skills necessary to operate and maintain the new automated systems. Additionally, the contract stipulated that any reduction in the workforce would be achieved through attrition rather than layoffs. This compromise, enshrined within the document, demonstrated a proactive approach to managing technological change, prioritizing the well-being of workers while acknowledging the need for modernization.
Ultimately, the handling of automation concerns within the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” set a precedent for future labor negotiations in industries facing similar technological shifts. The agreement highlighted the importance of proactive dialogue, investment in workforce development, and a commitment to mitigating the negative impacts of automation on workers. While the challenges posed by automation persist, the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” serves as a testament to the power of collective bargaining in shaping a more equitable and sustainable future for workers in the face of technological advancement. The negotiated terms offered a path, not of resistance, but of adaptation and shared progress.
4. Job Security
Within the digital confines of the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf,” the promise of job security wasn’t just a clause; it was the bedrock upon which livelihoods were built. For generations, longshore work represented a path to the middle class, a guarantee of stability in a volatile world. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” sought to uphold this tradition, navigating the complex realities of a changing industry while safeguarding the interests of its members.
-
Attrition Clauses
Attrition clauses represented a silent guardian. Rather than outright layoffs, the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” often stipulated that workforce reductions occur through retirement or voluntary departures. For example, if a shipping company sought to reduce its workforce by 10%, these clauses ensured that no existing employee would be involuntarily terminated. The reduction would occur as employees retired, leaving open positions unfilled. These clauses, while not eliminating the possibility of job losses entirely, provided a buffer, offering workers time to adapt and explore alternative opportunities.
-
Retraining Programs
The shifting sands of technology demanded adaptability. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” often included provisions for retraining programs, equipping workers with the skills needed to operate new equipment and navigate evolving job roles. Imagine a longshoreman who spent years operating a traditional crane. With the introduction of automated systems, his skills might become obsolete. Retraining programs, funded and mandated by the contract, would allow him to learn how to maintain and troubleshoot these new systems, ensuring his continued employment in a modernizing industry.
-
Jurisdictional Protections
The definition of “longshore work” became a battleground. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” fiercely guarded the union’s jurisdiction, preventing employers from outsourcing traditionally unionized jobs to non-union workers or automated systems. For instance, if a shipping company attempted to contract out the work of container repair to a non-union shop, the jurisdictional protections within the agreement would prevent this, ensuring that union members retained those jobs. This protection served as a bulwark against erosion of the union’s bargaining power and the livelihoods of its members.
-
Guaranteed Minimum Income
Fluctuations in global trade can lead to unpredictable workloads on the docks. Recognizing this reality, the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” sometimes included provisions for a guaranteed minimum income, providing a safety net for workers during periods of low activity. For example, even if a longshoreman’s work hours were significantly reduced due to a slowdown in shipping, the contract would guarantee a minimum level of pay, allowing him to meet his basic needs and avoid financial hardship. This provision offered a crucial layer of security in an industry subject to the ebb and flow of global commerce.
The job security measures embedded within the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” represented more than just legal obligations; they reflected a commitment to the well-being of the workforce and the stability of port communities. These measures acknowledged the human cost of economic change and sought to mitigate its impact, ensuring that longshore work remained a viable path to a secure future. The document became a symbol of resilience, a testament to the power of collective bargaining in safeguarding the livelihoods of working families.
5. Dispute Resolution
The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf,” while meticulously crafted, could not foresee every disagreement, every unforeseen circumstance. Embedded within its clauses was a mechanism for navigating the inevitable conflicts: a robust dispute resolution process. This process, far from being a mere formality, represented the contract’s safety valve, preventing disagreements from escalating into disruptive work stoppages and preserving the delicate balance between labor and management. The absence of such a mechanism would render the agreement fragile, susceptible to collapse under the weight of unresolved issues.
-
Grievance Procedures
The grievance procedure formed the foundation of dispute resolution. A longshoreman, believing his rights under the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” had been violated perhaps denied overtime pay, unfairly disciplined, or assigned unsafe work could initiate a formal grievance. This process, typically involving several stages of review and negotiation, allowed both sides to present their case. For instance, a crane operator unjustly suspended for alleged negligence could file a grievance, leading to an investigation that might uncover mitigating circumstances and overturn the suspension. The grievance procedure ensured that every worker had a voice, a means of challenging perceived injustices within the framework of the agreement. The steps are usually well defined in ilwu contract 2023 pdf.
-
Mediation
When grievance procedures stalled, mediation often served as a bridge. A neutral third party, trained in conflict resolution, would facilitate discussions between labor and management, seeking common ground and guiding them towards a mutually acceptable solution. Consider a dispute over the interpretation of a complex clause regarding automation. Mediation could bring in an expert in labor law to clarify the clause’s intent, helping both sides understand their obligations and reach a compromise. Mediation provided an alternative to adversarial legal proceedings, preserving relationships and fostering a more collaborative approach to resolving disagreements. This step could avoid wasting money both sides.
-
Arbitration
Arbitration represented the final step, the ultimate decision-making authority. If mediation failed, the dispute would be submitted to an impartial arbitrator, whose ruling would be binding on both parties. Imagine a disagreement over the appropriate staffing levels for a new automated terminal. Both the union and management present evidence and arguments to the arbitrator, who then renders a decision based on the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” and relevant labor laws. Arbitration provided a definitive resolution, preventing disputes from festering and disrupting port operations. However, since the solution is legally binding for both side, so preparing for a proper solution is necessary before the Arbitration step.
-
Joint Labor-Management Committees
Proactive prevention proved as crucial as reactive resolution. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” often established joint labor-management committees, forums for ongoing dialogue and collaboration. These committees addressed potential sources of conflict before they escalated into formal disputes. For instance, a committee might discuss proposed changes to work rules, solicit input from workers, and address concerns before the changes are implemented. These committees fostered a sense of shared ownership and responsibility, promoting a more harmonious and productive work environment. Open communication can bring better understanding, thus avoiding many disputes.
The dispute resolution mechanisms enshrined within the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” were not merely procedural requirements. They embodied a commitment to fairness, a recognition that disagreements were inevitable, and a belief that they could be resolved through dialogue and compromise. These mechanisms ensured that the agreement remained a living document, adaptable to changing circumstances and capable of weathering the storms of labor relations. The process is like a safety valve, protecting both sides and thus the whole system.
6. Training Programs
The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” became more than a list of rules when it addressed the future. The story of longshore work has always been one of physical strength and grit, passed down through generations. But the rise of automation and technological advancement threatened to make those skills obsolete. To bridge that gap, training programs became a crucial element of the contract, a promise of adaptation rather than displacement.
Consider the container crane operators, once masters of their towering machines. Suddenly, they faced computer screens and automated systems. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf,” recognizing this challenge, mandated retraining programs. These programs weren’t mere token gestures; they were comprehensive curricula designed to equip seasoned workers with the skills necessary to operate and maintain the new technologies. Without those programs, many would have been left behind, their experience rendered irrelevant. These programs also opened opportunities for younger longshoremen to advance quicker.
In essence, the inclusion of robust training programs within the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” signifies a shift in perspective. It acknowledges that the value of labor extends beyond physical strength. It also includes adaptability and a willingness to learn. The contract doesn’t simply protect jobs; it invests in the people who perform them, ensuring that the workforce remains relevant and competitive in a rapidly changing global economy. This commitment to ongoing education and skill development represents a powerful step towards securing the future of longshore work, one guided by both tradition and innovation. If we ignore that, it will slowly become a dinosaur.
7. Safety Protocols
Within the pages of the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf,” the section on safety protocols held a significance beyond mere legal obligations. For longshore workers, facing the daily risks inherent in handling heavy machinery and navigating bustling port environments, these protocols were the frontline defense against injury and even death. Each clause represented a hard-won victory, often forged in the aftermath of tragic accidents that underscored the perilous nature of the work. The inclusion of comprehensive safety measures was not simply a matter of compliance; it was a moral imperative, a testament to the union’s unwavering commitment to protecting the well-being of its members. The memory of past incidents served as a constant reminder of the importance of vigilance and the need for continuous improvement in safety practices.
Consider the story of a young longshoreman, eager to prove himself on the docks. He disregarded a seemingly minor safety protocol, rushing to secure a container without properly inspecting the locking mechanism. A sudden shift in the cargo caused the container to swing, narrowly missing him but resulting in a serious injury to a nearby colleague. This incident, investigated thoroughly, led to a renewed emphasis on adherence to safety protocols, with increased training and stricter enforcement measures incorporated into the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf.” It served as a stark reminder that even seemingly insignificant deviations from established procedures could have devastating consequences. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” also encouraged for more safety regulations, not only during working hours, but during lunch time and rest period.
The safety protocols outlined in the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” were therefore more than just rules; they were a living embodiment of lessons learned, a collective effort to create a safer and more secure working environment. By rigorously enforcing these protocols and continuously seeking ways to improve them, the union and management demonstrated a shared commitment to protecting the lives and livelihoods of those who worked on the docks. The contract ensured the constant review of those protocols to adapt to any circumstances, in order to make sure the longshoremen could operate smoothly and safety.
8. Contract Duration
The lifespan of the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” represents more than just a period of time; it embodies a strategic calculation, a delicate balance between stability and responsiveness. The duration, whether spanning three years, five years, or some other interval, dictates the rhythm of labor relations on the West Coast, influencing everything from investment decisions to long-term workforce planning. It is within this temporal frame that the terms and conditions outlined in the agreement take effect, shaping the daily lives of longshore workers and the operational efficiency of the ports.
-
Economic Forecasting
The length of the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” hinges on economic predictions. A shorter duration might be preferred when economic uncertainty looms, allowing both parties to revisit the agreement sooner in response to changing conditions. For example, during a period of rapid inflation or technological disruption, a shorter contract cycle provides flexibility to adjust wages, benefits, and job security provisions more quickly. Conversely, a longer duration can provide stability during periods of economic growth, fostering investor confidence and facilitating long-term infrastructure development. The decision reflects a gamble on the future, a calculated assessment of the economic landscape.
-
Bargaining Power Dynamics
The contract’s duration mirrors the relative bargaining power of the ILWU and the employers. If the union holds significant leverage, it might push for a shorter duration, allowing it to renegotiate more frequently and capitalize on favorable economic conditions. Conversely, if employers have the upper hand, they might seek a longer duration to lock in favorable terms and avoid the uncertainty of frequent negotiations. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” is thus a snapshot of the power dynamics at play during the negotiation process, a tangible representation of the balance of forces between labor and management.
-
Impact on Investment Decisions
The contract duration impacts long-term investment in port infrastructure. A longer contract provides greater certainty for employers, encouraging them to invest in new equipment, technology, and facilities. Imagine a shipping company contemplating a multi-million dollar upgrade to its terminal. The company’s willingness to proceed with the investment hinges, in part, on the stability of labor relations. A long-term agreement, like the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” with a five-year duration, provides the necessary assurance, allowing the company to recoup its investment over time. Conversely, a short-term contract creates uncertainty, potentially deterring long-term capital expenditures.
-
Cycle of Negotiations
The duration establishes the rhythm for future negotiations. A shorter contract cycle means more frequent rounds of bargaining, creating a recurring cycle of potential disruption. Conversely, a longer duration provides a period of relative calm, allowing both parties to focus on operational efficiency and long-term planning. However, a longer cycle also means that any unresolved issues or emerging challenges will remain in place for a longer period. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” sets the stage for the next round of negotiations, shaping the agenda and influencing the tone of future discussions.
The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” and its established time frame are more than legal agreements; they are living documents that greatly impact the stability of labor and trade. This affects the entire West Coast, influencing workforce satisfaction, and the competitiveness of ports in the global market.
Frequently Asked Questions
Navigating the complexities of a labor agreement can be daunting. The following questions address common inquiries regarding the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf,” offering clarity on its key aspects and implications.
Question 1: Where does one locate an official copy of this agreement?
Acquiring the authentic document is paramount. Unofficial sources often circulate, rife with inaccuracies. The definitive source rests with either the International Longshore and Warehouse Union (ILWU) directly or authorized employer representatives party to the agreement. Requests submitted through official channels ensure access to the ratified and legally binding version. The importance of this can not be understated.
Question 2: What is the specific duration of the terms outlined within?
Understanding the contract’s timeline is crucial. Unlike fleeting arrangements, the terms of the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” are not indefinite. The agreement specifies a start date, 2023, and an end date, typically spanning several years. The exact duration, often three to five years, dictates the period during which the negotiated wages, benefits, and working conditions remain in effect. This duration impacts long-term planning for both workers and employers.
Question 3: How are wage adjustments determined and implemented?
The matter of compensation forms a central pillar. The document details the methodology for wage adjustments, often incorporating a combination of factors. Base wage increases, scheduled increments over the contract’s life, and cost-of-living adjustments (COLAs), designed to offset inflation, are common components. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” meticulously outlines how these adjustments are calculated and when they take effect, ensuring transparency and predictability.
Question 4: What provisions address the increasing implementation of automation?
The rise of technology poses a significant challenge. The agreement acknowledges the potential impact of automation on longshore work, outlining measures to mitigate job displacement. Retraining programs, designed to equip workers with the skills needed to operate new technologies, and attrition clauses, limiting workforce reductions to voluntary departures, are often included. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” seeks to balance technological advancement with the protection of workers’ livelihoods.
Question 5: How does this agreement define protocols for conflict resolution between employees and employers?
Disagreements are inevitable in any workplace. The agreement establishes a multi-tiered dispute resolution process, designed to address grievances fairly and efficiently. Grievance procedures, mediation, and arbitration provide avenues for resolving conflicts, preventing minor disputes from escalating into disruptive work stoppages. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” ensures that both workers and employers have access to a structured and impartial process for resolving their differences.
Question 6: Beyond base pay, what specific healthcare benefits are provided to union members?
Healthcare security is vital. The document outlines the comprehensive healthcare benefits provided to ILWU members and their families. This often includes medical, dental, and vision coverage, as well as provisions for prescription drugs and mental health services. The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” details the specific coverage levels, co-pays, and deductibles, providing clarity on the healthcare benefits available to union members.
Understanding the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” requires careful examination and attention to detail. This FAQ provides a starting point, offering insights into some of the most frequently asked questions surrounding this important labor agreement.
The next section will elaborate on [Next Section Topic].
Navigating the Waters
The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf,” while a specific document, offers broader lessons applicable to any negotiation, any agreement seeking lasting stability. Its intricate details reveal strategies, insights gleaned from decades of labor relations on the West Coast. The following are glimpses into those lessons, distilled from the very clauses and provisions that shape the lives of longshore workers.
Tip 1: Document Everything Meticulously
The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” is a testament to the power of precise language. Every clause, every definition is scrutinized, debated, and refined. Ambiguity breeds conflict. Therefore, document every agreement, every understanding, with painstaking detail. If something is not written down, it does not exist. This extends beyond the final contract; maintain records of all negotiations, proposals, and counter-proposals. These records can prove invaluable in resolving disputes and ensuring accountability.
Tip 2: Prioritize Clear Communication Channels
The formal dispute resolution process outlined in the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” highlights the importance of clear communication. Establish open and reliable channels for dialogue between all parties. Regular meetings, joint committees, and transparent reporting mechanisms can prevent misunderstandings and foster a more collaborative environment. The goal is to address concerns before they escalate into formal grievances.
Tip 3: Anticipate Future Challenges
The provisions addressing automation within the document underscore the need for foresight. A successful agreement does not simply address current issues; it anticipates future challenges. Consider emerging technologies, economic trends, and demographic shifts. Build flexibility into the agreement, allowing for adjustments in response to unforeseen circumstances. This requires a willingness to engage in continuous dialogue and adapt to a changing landscape.
Tip 4: Invest in Workforce Development
The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf”‘s emphasis on training programs reveals a crucial insight: a skilled workforce is a valuable asset. Invest in the development of employees. Provide opportunities for ongoing education, skill enhancement, and career advancement. This not only benefits individual workers but also strengthens the organization as a whole, fostering innovation and improving productivity. Training is not merely an expense; it is an investment in the future.
Tip 5: Establish Fair and Impartial Dispute Resolution Mechanisms
The robust dispute resolution process embedded within the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” emphasizes the importance of fairness. Create mechanisms for resolving conflicts that are perceived as impartial and equitable. These mechanisms should be accessible to all parties, providing a means of addressing grievances without fear of reprisal. A fair and transparent dispute resolution process fosters trust and reduces the likelihood of protracted conflicts.
Tip 6: Seek Mutual Benefit, Not Just Victory
While negotiations often involve compromise, the ultimate goal should not be simply to “win.” A truly successful agreement seeks mutual benefit. Identify common interests and strive to create solutions that benefit all parties involved. This requires a willingness to understand the perspectives of others and to find creative solutions that address their needs. A win-win approach fosters long-term relationships and promotes a more sustainable and collaborative environment.
Tip 7: Understand the Historical Context
The “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” did not emerge in a vacuum. It is the product of decades of labor relations, shaped by historical events, legal precedents, and the personalities of those involved. Before entering into negotiations, take the time to understand the historical context. Research past agreements, identify key issues, and learn from past successes and failures. A deep understanding of the history will provide valuable insights and inform the negotiation strategy.
These lessons, gleaned from the intricate details of a single labor agreement, offer broader guidance for anyone seeking to navigate the complexities of negotiation and build lasting stability. The principles of clear communication, foresight, fairness, and mutual benefit are applicable to any relationship, any agreement seeking to create a more equitable and sustainable future.
The next section will transition to a concluding summary, tying together the key themes explored throughout the article.
The Echo of Agreement
The digital echo of agreement, the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf,” represents far more than pixels on a screen. It is a story woven from threads of negotiation, compromise, and a steadfast commitment to the livelihoods of longshore workers. The preceding exploration revealed the document’s intricate tapestry: wage adjustments reflecting economic realities, healthcare provisions safeguarding well-being, and measures addressing the anxieties of automation. The clauses pertaining to job security, dispute resolution, training, and safety protocols, each a chapter in this narrative, underscored the ongoing effort to balance progress with the human cost of labor.
The narrative encoded within the “ilwu contract 2023 pdf” extends beyond the docks, resonating across industries facing similar challenges. It serves as a potent reminder that agreements, when forged with diligence, foresight, and a genuine commitment to mutual benefit, can provide stability amidst turbulent times. The next chapter in this ongoing story remains unwritten. The principles enshrined in this agreement will hopefully continue to guide stakeholders toward equitable and sustainable solutions, ensuring that the future of labor remains one of shared prosperity and enduring dignity.
