The ability to initiate an insurance request for compensation following a vehicle collision when formal law enforcement documentation is absent is a frequently encountered situation. This scenario typically arises when the incident is minor, lacking significant damage or injuries, and the involved parties mutually agree to resolve the matter privately. Circumstances might also include situations where police are unavailable or choose not to attend the scene.
The potential to proceed with a claim in the absence of official police records offers flexibility and can expedite the resolution process. This approach can be particularly beneficial in preventing increased insurance premiums for minor incidents and allows individuals to avoid the potential delays and complexities associated with formal legal proceedings. Historically, relying solely on police reports was the standard, but modern insurance practices often accommodate alternative forms of evidence.
This article will explore the conditions under which an insurance request can be successfully processed without official law enforcement documentation, acceptable forms of alternative evidence, potential challenges that may arise, and strategies for maximizing the chances of a successful outcome.
1. Evidence collection is crucial.
In scenarios devoid of an official police report, the burden of proof shifts dramatically to the claimant. The meticulous gathering and preservation of evidence becomes not merely advisable, but an absolute necessity for substantiating the incident and securing a fair settlement.
-
Photographic and Video Documentation
The camera becomes the unbiased observer in the absence of law enforcement. Crisp, detailed photographs of vehicle positions, damage extent, road conditions, and surrounding environment serve as a visual record. Videos, if available from dashcams or nearby surveillance, can provide a dynamic account of the impact and contributing factors. These visuals collectively paint a clearer picture for the insurance adjuster, mitigating potential disputes over liability and damage severity.
-
Witness Testimony: Independent Corroboration
Independent witnesses can serve as valuable corroborating sources. Acquiring written statements from individuals who observed the collision can reinforce the claimant’s account of events. These statements should include the witness’s contact information, a detailed description of what they saw, and their perspective on fault. Witness testimony adds credibility and reduces the likelihood of the insurance company questioning the validity of the claim.
-
Personal Documentation and Records
Beyond the immediate scene, detailed personal documentation is essential. Keep records of communication with the other driver, including any admissions of fault. Maintain meticulous records of all medical treatments, physical therapy sessions, and associated costs. These documents establish the extent of injuries and related financial losses, solidifying the claim for medical expenses and potential lost wages.
-
Expert Assessments: Objective Analysis
In complex cases, particularly those involving significant damage or injuries, enlisting expert assessments can be invaluable. A qualified mechanic can provide a detailed evaluation of the vehicle’s damage, while a medical professional can offer an independent assessment of the injuries sustained. These expert opinions offer an objective analysis that can strengthen the claim and counter any attempts by the insurance company to minimize the settlement.
The absence of a police report transforms the claimant into an investigator. Each piece of evidence gathered, no matter how small, contributes to constructing a compelling narrative. A well-documented case, meticulously assembled, significantly increases the likelihood of a successful claim resolution, even when formal law enforcement documentation is lacking. The claimant’s diligence in evidence collection becomes the cornerstone of their pursuit for just compensation.
2. Witness statements can help.
In the quiet aftermath of a collision, when the flashing lights of law enforcement are absent and a formal police report remains unwritten, the weight of substantiating an insurance claim falls heavily upon the involved parties. In these circumstances, the accounts of impartial observers, those who witnessed the event unfold, become invaluable. Their testimonies can bridge the gap left by the lack of official documentation, offering a crucial layer of validation to the claimant’s narrative.
-
Establishing Liability: The Impartial Observer
Witness statements serve as unbiased reconstructions of the event. Their accounts, free from the inherent biases of the involved drivers, can clarify the sequence of events leading to the collision and, critically, establish fault. Imagine a scenario where two vehicles collide at an intersection. Without a police report, determining who ran the red light becomes a matter of contention. A witness, positioned on the sidewalk, provides a statement affirming that one driver clearly disregarded the signal. This independent confirmation can be the deciding factor in assigning liability.
-
Corroborating the Narrative: Lending Credibility
Even when liability is not in dispute, the accuracy of the claimant’s description of the accident can be challenged. Witness statements bolster the claimant’s version of events, adding credibility to their assertions regarding speed, weather conditions, and other contributing factors. For instance, if the claimant alleges that the other driver was speeding, a witness statement confirming excessive speed prior to the impact strengthens the argument and mitigates the risk of the insurance company questioning the severity of the impact.
-
Countering Discrepancies: Resolving Ambiguity
Frequently, conflicting accounts of an accident emerge, particularly when emotions are high and memories are clouded. Witness statements can resolve ambiguities and address discrepancies in the narratives provided by the involved parties. Consider a situation where both drivers claim to have had the right-of-way when entering a roundabout. A witness, observing from a nearby building, provides a clear account indicating which vehicle entered the roundabout first, thereby resolving the conflict and establishing precedence.
The power of a witness statement lies in its objectivity. It is an untainted perspective offered by someone with no vested interest in the outcome of the claim. In situations where a police report is absent, these statements are not merely helpful; they are often indispensable in building a credible and compelling case for compensation. They provide the necessary validation and clarity to navigate the complexities of the insurance claim process and secure a fair resolution.
3. Photos of damage matter.
In the realm of automotive collisions, the absence of a police report casts a long shadow of uncertainty. Within this shadow, the role of visual evidence, specifically photographs meticulously capturing the damage sustained, takes on a heightened significance. These images transcend mere documentation; they become the narrative, the corroboration, the very foundation upon which a successful insurance claim can be built.
-
Quantifying Loss: The Language of Visuals
Photographs translate the intangible concept of “damage” into a tangible, quantifiable assessment of loss. A crumpled fender, a shattered headlight, a deployed airbag each element captured in detail provides an adjuster with a clear understanding of the impact’s severity and the subsequent cost of repairs. In the absence of a police assessment, these visuals become the primary source of information for evaluating the extent of the damage, directly influencing the settlement offer. Imagine a scenario where a minor fender-bender occurs in a parking lot. Without a police report, the insurance company might downplay the damage. However, high-resolution photographs revealing underlying structural damage can force a reassessment and a more equitable settlement.
-
Establishing Causation: The Chain of Events
Beyond the mere presence of damage, photographs can help establish a clear chain of causation. By capturing the angles of impact, the distribution of debris, and the relative positions of the vehicles, these images reconstruct the collision event, painting a visual story of how the damage occurred. This is particularly crucial when fault is in dispute. For instance, photographs showing tire marks leading directly to a collision point can provide compelling evidence of speeding or reckless driving, even without a police officer’s expert opinion.
-
Protecting Against Fraud: The Veracity of Imagery
In the unfortunate event of a deliberately staged collision, photographs serve as a powerful safeguard against fraudulent claims. Close-up images revealing pre-existing damage, inconsistent impact patterns, or a lack of corresponding injuries can expose discrepancies and prevent insurance companies from being defrauded. The camera becomes a tool for uncovering deception and ensuring that legitimate claims are not unfairly burdened by fraudulent activities. A seemingly minor detail, captured in a photograph, can be the key to unraveling a fraudulent scheme.
-
Negotiating Leverage: The Power of Proof
Presenting a well-documented collection of photographs strengthens the claimant’s negotiating position. In the absence of a police report, the burden of proof rests squarely on the claimant’s shoulders. By providing irrefutable visual evidence of the damage sustained, the claimant demonstrates the validity of their claim and reduces the likelihood of the insurance company challenging the assessment or delaying settlement. High-quality photographs, presented professionally, convey a message of seriousness and preparedness, significantly enhancing the claimant’s ability to secure a fair and timely resolution.
Thus, in the landscape where “Can you file an accident claim without a police report”, photographs of damage are not merely supplementary; they are fundamental. They provide the eyes, the voice, and the undeniable proof necessary to navigate the complexities of the claims process and secure just compensation.
4. Medical records add weight.
In the quiet rooms of hospitals and clinics, a narrative unfolds, meticulously documented in charts and diagnostic reports. These medical records, often overlooked in the immediate aftermath of a vehicular incident where law enforcement doesn’t create an official report, possess a unique power. They serve as an undeniable testament to the physical toll exacted by the collision, lending substantial credence to an insurance claim proceeding without police intervention.
-
Establishing Injury Causation: Linking Trauma to Impact
Consider the driver, shaken but outwardly unharmed after a low-speed collision. No police report is filed. Days later, persistent neck pain emerges, diagnosed as whiplash. The medical records, detailing the initial examination, subsequent treatments, and physician’s assessment linking the injury to the collision, provide irrefutable evidence. Without these records, the insurance company might dismiss the claim, arguing that the injury was pre-existing or unrelated. The records establish a clear and traceable connection between the incident and the claimant’s suffering, a critical factor in securing compensation.
-
Quantifying Pain and Suffering: Beyond the Visible Scars
Injuries often extend beyond the visible. Chronic pain, emotional distress, and psychological trauma can linger long after the physical wounds have healed. Medical records documenting therapy sessions, prescription medications, and mental health evaluations provide tangible evidence of these intangible damages. They allow the claimant to articulate the full extent of their suffering, translating emotional distress into quantifiable terms that the insurance company can acknowledge and compensate. A therapist’s notes detailing anxiety and post-traumatic stress following an accident, for example, can significantly increase the value of a claim, especially in the absence of a police report that might otherwise highlight the severity of the incident.
-
Demonstrating Treatment Necessity: Justifying Medical Expenses
Insurance companies often scrutinize medical bills, questioning the necessity and reasonableness of the treatment provided. Medical records serve as a critical defense against such challenges. Detailed notes from physicians, physical therapists, and other healthcare providers justify the prescribed treatments, demonstrating that they were medically necessary and directly related to the injuries sustained in the collision. These records counter attempts to minimize the claimant’s medical expenses, ensuring that they receive full compensation for their healthcare costs. A doctor’s detailed explanation of why a specific type of physical therapy was required to restore mobility can be decisive in securing reimbursement.
-
Creating a Chronological Record: Showing Persistence of Symptoms
Often, symptoms of an injury don’t appear immediately after an accident. Medical records can establish a timeline of symptoms and treatment, and in turn, can validate the impact of the accident. By documenting these over time, the injured party has a far better chance of getting the claim approved, because a timeline is in place.
In essence, when seeking compensation without the formal authority of law enforcement documentation, medical records become the claimant’s advocate, articulating the often-silent narrative of pain and suffering. They transform the subjective experience of injury into an objective, verifiable reality, lending substantial weight to the claim and significantly increasing the likelihood of a just and equitable resolution. They are the cornerstone of credibility in the absence of flashing lights and official reports.
5. Insurance policy terms apply.
The question of initiating an insurance claim without an official police report inevitably leads to a critical examination of the governing contract: the insurance policy itself. It is within these pages, often overlooked until a crisis arises, that the parameters of coverage are defined, the responsibilities of the insured are outlined, and the procedures for claim submission are meticulously detailed. Navigating the absence of a police report necessitates a thorough understanding of these contractual obligations.
-
Notification Requirements: Adhering to Timelines
Most insurance policies stipulate specific timeframes within which an incident must be reported. Failure to adhere to these timelines, regardless of whether a police report exists, can jeopardize the claim. For example, a policy might require notification within 24 or 48 hours of the accident. Delaying notification, even in the absence of a police report, could provide the insurer with grounds to deny coverage, arguing that the delay hindered their ability to investigate the incident effectively. The insured bears the responsibility of knowing and adhering to these reporting deadlines.
-
Cooperation Clause: Assisting the Investigation
Insurance policies typically include a cooperation clause, obligating the insured to assist the insurer in its investigation of the claim. This includes providing access to relevant information, such as photographs, witness statements, and medical records. Refusal to cooperate, or providing misleading information, can invalidate the claim, even if the incident itself is covered under the policy. In the context of no police report, the insured’s proactive cooperation becomes even more critical, as they are essentially filling the investigative void left by law enforcement.
-
Proof of Loss: Demonstrating the Extent of Damages
The burden of proving the extent of damages rests squarely on the insured, and insurance policies often outline the acceptable forms of evidence. While a police report is a common form of evidence, it is not always mandatory. However, the policy may specify alternative forms of acceptable proof, such as repair estimates, medical bills, and photographs of the damage. The insured must carefully review the policy to understand what documentation is required to substantiate the claim in the absence of a police report. Failing to provide adequate proof of loss can result in a denial of coverage.
-
Exclusions and Limitations: Understanding What Isn’t Covered
Every insurance policy contains exclusions and limitations, defining the circumstances under which coverage will not be provided. These exclusions might pertain to specific types of accidents, certain drivers, or particular types of damage. For example, a policy might exclude coverage for incidents involving uninsured drivers, or for damage caused by intentional acts. Before filing a claim without a police report, it is crucial to review the policy’s exclusions and limitations to ensure that the incident falls within the scope of coverage. Filing a claim for an excluded event is likely to be futile, regardless of whether a police report exists.
The intersection of policy terms and the absence of a police report highlights the importance of proactive due diligence on the part of the insured. Understanding the policy’s obligations, adhering to notification timelines, cooperating with the insurer’s investigation, and providing adequate proof of loss are all crucial steps in navigating the claim process successfully. The insurance policy is the governing document, and its terms must be carefully considered and diligently followed to maximize the chances of a favorable outcome when seeking compensation without formal law enforcement documentation.
6. Negotiation skills are useful.
The crumpled metal sat as a silent testament to the afternoon’s events. No flashing lights had broken the suburban tranquility, no official report documenting the precise ballet of misjudgment that led to the collision. Mr. Henderson, a retired accountant with a lifetime of careful budgeting, faced a daunting task: securing compensation for his dented fender armed only with photographs, witness accounts, and his own resolve. The insurance adjuster, a seasoned professional accustomed to navigating the nuances of liability, presented an initial offer that barely covered the cost of parts. It was at this moment that Mr. Henderson’s negotiation skills, honed over years of business dealings, became his most valuable asset. The ability to articulate the sequence of events clearly, to present the supporting evidence persuasively, and to understand the adjuster’s constraints proved crucial in shifting the dynamic of the discussion. He respectfully countered the initial offer, highlighting the corroborating witness statements and the detailed repair estimate he had obtained. He knew his case, understood the adjuster’s position, and never lost his composure.
The absence of a police report invariably creates an asymmetry of information, often favoring the insurance company. Negotiation skills level the playing field, empowering the claimant to advocate for their interests with confidence and clarity. It is not merely about haggling over numbers; it’s about presenting a compelling case, understanding the underlying legal and contractual principles, and building rapport with the adjuster. An amicable tone, coupled with a firm understanding of the facts, can often yield results that are far superior to those achieved through aggression or intimidation. Recognizing the adjuster’s authority to make decisions, but also their responsibility to act in good faith, allows for a productive dialogue aimed at reaching a mutually acceptable resolution. The skills of active listening, assertive communication, and creative problem-solving are particularly valuable in these situations. Knowing when to concede on minor points to gain ground on more substantial issues, and when to stand firm on principle, is the mark of a skilled negotiator.
The ability to engage in effective negotiation transforms the landscape of an accident claim filed without a police report. It elevates the claimant from a passive recipient of an offer to an active participant in the resolution process. While thorough documentation and legal counsel remain valuable resources, negotiation skills provide the crucial human element necessary to navigate the complexities of the insurance system and secure a just outcome. In essence, when the formal authority of a police report is absent, the art of negotiation becomes the claimant’s most powerful tool in the pursuit of fairness and compensation.
7. Legal counsel may assist.
When the screech of tires fades and the dust settles, the absence of a police report after a collision can create a legal vacuum. In this void, the expertise of legal counsel often proves invaluable, transforming a landscape of uncertainty into one of strategic advantage.
-
Navigating Complex Liability Disputes
Consider a scenario where two vehicles sideswipe each other on a rain-slicked highway, and fault is far from clear. Without an official determination from law enforcement, each driver might claim the other’s negligence. Legal counsel can meticulously gather evidence, interview witnesses, and reconstruct the accident scene to build a compelling case, potentially using expert accident reconstructionists to determine the dynamics of the crash. This approach can bring clarity to a murky situation, ultimately establishing liability and securing a favorable settlement or judgment.
-
Interpreting Insurance Policy Nuances
Insurance policies, often dense with legal jargon, can be challenging for the average person to decipher. Clauses, exclusions, and limitations can significantly impact the validity and value of a claim. Legal counsel, experienced in insurance law, can dissect the policy language, identify potential coverage loopholes, and advocate for the client’s rights. In the absence of a police report, this expertise is particularly crucial, as the insurance company might attempt to deny or minimize the claim based on a narrow interpretation of the policy.
-
Negotiating with Insurance Adjusters
Insurance adjusters, while often professional, are ultimately tasked with protecting their employer’s financial interests. Legal counsel can act as a buffer between the claimant and the adjuster, negotiating on the client’s behalf with a deep understanding of the relevant laws and precedents. They can effectively counter lowball offers, highlight the full extent of the damages, and ensure that the claimant receives fair compensation for their injuries, property damage, and other losses. The presence of legal representation often signals to the insurance company that the claimant is serious and prepared to pursue litigation if necessary, which can incentivize a more reasonable settlement offer.
-
Representing Clients in Litigation
Despite best efforts, some insurance claims cannot be resolved through negotiation. In these situations, legal counsel can file a lawsuit and represent the client in court, presenting evidence, examining witnesses, and arguing the case before a judge or jury. Litigation is a complex and time-consuming process, but it may be the only option for securing justice when the insurance company refuses to offer a fair settlement. The expertise of legal counsel in navigating the court system and presenting a compelling case can significantly increase the likelihood of a successful outcome.
The potential to file a claim lacking a police report introduces complexities that often warrant legal guidance. In such instances, consulting legal counsel isn’t merely a suggestion, but a strategic move to navigate the intricacies of insurance claims and secure rightful compensation.
Frequently Asked Questions
The process of seeking compensation following a vehicular incident often raises numerous questions, particularly when a formal police report is absent. The following addresses common concerns and provides clarity on navigating this complex situation.
Question 1: Is initiating an insurance claim permissible without a police report?
Circumstances frequently arise where a formal police investigation is not conducted following an accident. Perhaps the incident was minor, occurring in a private parking lot with minimal damage. Or, perhaps the authorities were unavailable to respond. In such instances, initiating an insurance claim remains permissible, although the burden of proof shifts significantly to the claimant. Comprehensive documentation, including photographs, witness statements, and medical records, becomes crucial in substantiating the claim.
Question 2: What types of evidence are acceptable when a police report is not available?
The absence of an official police account necessitates a proactive approach to evidence gathering. Photographs of the accident scene, capturing vehicle positions and damage, serve as visual documentation. Witness statements from impartial observers provide corroborating accounts. Medical records detail injuries sustained. Repair estimates quantify property damage. Communication records with the other driver, including any admissions of fault, add further weight to the claim. The more comprehensive the evidence package, the stronger the position.
Question 3: Are there specific instances where a police report is absolutely required?
Certain insurance policies may stipulate the submission of a police report for specific types of incidents, such as those involving hit-and-run drivers or suspected criminal activity. High value damage is another likely scenario. Furthermore, incidents resulting in serious injury or fatality typically necessitate a formal police investigation. Reviewing the insurance policy meticulously is essential to understanding the specific requirements for claim submission.
Question 4: How does the absence of a police report affect the determination of fault?
Without an official police determination of fault, the insurance companies involved will conduct their own investigations, relying on the available evidence. This process can be more protracted and contentious when a police report is lacking. The claimant must proactively present compelling evidence to support their version of events and demonstrate the other driver’s negligence. Failure to do so can result in a denial of the claim or a shared liability determination.
Question 5: What recourse is available if an insurance claim is denied due to the lack of a police report?
If an insurance claim is denied solely due to the absence of a police report, several avenues for recourse exist. The claimant can appeal the decision, providing additional evidence and a detailed explanation of the circumstances. Engaging with a neutral third party, such as a mediator, can facilitate a resolution. Finally, consulting with an attorney specializing in insurance law can provide legal guidance and potentially lead to litigation if necessary.
Question 6: Does the absence of a police report impact the value of the claim?
While the underlying damages remain the same regardless of whether a police report exists, the absence of such documentation can indirectly impact the perceived value of the claim. Insurance companies may view claims lacking a police report with greater scrutiny, potentially offering lower settlements. Conversely, a well-documented claim, supported by strong evidence, can command a fair and equitable settlement, even without the weight of official police findings.
Successfully navigating an insurance claim without a police report hinges on meticulous documentation, proactive communication, and a thorough understanding of insurance policy terms. Legal counsel can provide invaluable assistance in complex situations.
The following section will explore strategies for maximizing the chances of a successful outcome when proceeding without a police report.
Navigating the Claims Process Without a Police Report
The road ahead after a car accident can be fraught with uncertainty, particularly when a police report is absent. However, this absence doesn’t automatically equate to a dead end. With careful planning and strategic action, securing a fair settlement remains possible. The following recommendations offer guidance in navigating this complex terrain.
Tip 1: Prioritize Immediate Documentation
The moments following a collision are critical. The temptation to simply exchange information and move on must be resisted. Instead, focus on meticulously documenting the scene. Photographs, taken from multiple angles, should capture vehicle positions, damage to all involved vehicles, road conditions, and any relevant surrounding details like traffic signals or signage. These images form the visual bedrock of the claim, particularly when official documentation is lacking. Remember, these images may be the only objective record of the event.
Tip 2: Secure Witness Information Proactively
Bystanders can provide invaluable corroboration, but memories fade quickly. Before leaving the scene, make a concerted effort to identify and obtain contact information from any individuals who witnessed the collision. A brief, written statement, signed and dated, outlining what they observed can significantly strengthen the claim. Even seemingly minor details recalled by a witness can prove crucial in resolving disputes over liability.
Tip 3: Seek Medical Attention Promptly, and Document Thoroughly
Even if injuries appear minor, a medical evaluation is essential. Many injuries, such as whiplash or concussions, manifest symptoms days or even weeks after the incident. Seeking prompt medical attention establishes a clear connection between the collision and any subsequent health issues. Maintain meticulous records of all medical visits, treatments, and related expenses. These records serve as concrete evidence of the damages suffered.
Tip 4: Notify the Insurance Company Immediately and Strategically
Delaying notification can raise suspicion and jeopardize the claim. However, it is crucial to avoid making any admissions of fault or speculating about the cause of the accident. Simply provide the essential facts: date, time, location, and a brief description of the incident. Defer detailed explanations until all evidence has been gathered and legal counsel has been consulted, if necessary.
Tip 5: Obtain Multiple Repair Estimates to Establish Fair Market Value
Relying solely on the insurance company’s preferred repair shop can lead to a lowball estimate. Obtain multiple estimates from reputable repair facilities to establish the fair market value of the necessary repairs. This demonstrates diligence and provides leverage during negotiations.
Tip 6: Consult with Legal Counsel Before Accepting Any Settlement Offer
Insurance companies often attempt to minimize payouts, particularly when a police report is absent. Consulting with an attorney specializing in accident claims can provide invaluable guidance on the true value of the claim and the legal options available. Legal counsel can also handle all communication with the insurance company, protecting the claimant from inadvertently making statements that could harm their case.
Tip 7: Maintain Detailed Records of All Communication and Expenses
From initial notification to final settlement, keep a detailed record of all communication with the insurance company, including dates, times, names of representatives, and summaries of conversations. Also, meticulously track all expenses related to the accident, such as medical bills, repair costs, rental car fees, and lost wages. This comprehensive record-keeping provides a solid foundation for negotiating a fair settlement or pursuing legal action, if necessary.
Tip 8: Be Prepared to Negotiate Patiently and Persistently
The insurance claim process can be lengthy and frustrating, particularly without a police report to expedite matters. Be prepared to negotiate patiently and persistently. Present the evidence clearly and concisely, and remain firm in pursuing a fair settlement that adequately compensates for all damages suffered. Remember, settling for less than what is rightfully deserved only benefits the insurance company.
By adopting these proactive strategies, individuals can significantly enhance their chances of securing a favorable outcome when filing an accident claim without a police report. Thorough documentation, proactive communication, and a willingness to advocate for one’s rights are essential elements of success.
The following section will summarize the key points discussed, reinforcing the importance of preparedness and proactive action when formal law enforcement documentation is absent.
Can You File an Accident Claim Without a Police Report
The preceding exploration illuminates the path one treads when seeking restitution after a collision, absent the familiar beacon of a police report. From meticulous evidence gathering to skillful negotiation, the ability to pursue a claim hinges on preparedness and diligence. Witness testimonies become vital chronicles, photographs transform into irrefutable narratives, and medical records whisper tales of suffering that demand acknowledgment. Insurance policies, those often-overlooked documents, wield power, dictating the rules of engagement. Legal counsel, like seasoned navigators, chart courses through turbulent legal waters.
Consider this not as an endpoint, but rather as a call to proactive vigilance. In a world where unforeseen events occur, the absence of a police report should not equate to a forfeiture of rights. Instead, understand that a proactive and informed approach can significantly influence the trajectory of the claim process. The power to secure just compensation rests with those who are prepared to document, advocate, and, when necessary, seek expert guidance. Remember, the narrative of the accident, in the absence of law enforcement’s account, is yours to construct and defend.
